gentrification in west philadelphia
In the nineteenth century, West Philadelphia transformed from a countryside of family farms and "gentlemen's" estates to a set of residential communities. The Plans effects were keenly felt in the Black Bottom, a primarily black and disadvantaged neighborhood that earned its name from its place at the bottom of West Philadelphia (from 32nd Street to 40th Street between Lancaster Ave and University Ave). The poverty rate in Philadelphia as of 2019 was 23.3%, 13 percentage points above the U.S. national rate of 10.5%. Housing activists, university students, and residents have staged protests and encampments to defend low-income housing in UC Townhomes, PHILADELPHIA, PA - APRIL 30: Protestors march over the death of Freddie Gray on April 30, 2015 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. As middle-class residents returned, formerly moribund commercial corridors came alive with restaurants and shops catering to the well-heeled. Housing activists and UC Townhomes residents fight gentrification in West Philadelphia Housing activists, university students, and residents have staged protests and encampments to defend low-income housing in UC Townhomes by Jared Ware October 7th, 2022 Beginning in the late 1960s, the neighborhood began to change as some white middle-class pioneers were lured to the area by the promise of affordable housing near Center City. The old Gothic auditorium will be turned into a coworking space and a coffee shop. Rasheda Alexander, a resident council member at the development, remembers seeing a few organizers tabling near the parking lot on weekends in the winter. In 1970, the neighborhood had only 90 housing units; by 1990, it had 1,665. In recent years, a number of Philadelphia neighborhoods have undergone significant transformation, with higher-income residents moving in, real estate prices rising, new businesses . For the city and real estate developers, it served as a hopeful model for neighborhood revitalization. Methodology & Disclaimers Sandy Smith In effect, Penn undermined its own efforts to serve its proximate community, by replacing residents with more of their own. The month-long encampment in the Townhomes courtyard by residents and supporters was one of the watershed moments in the fight. Is Philadelphia a gentrification? The student solidarity work has drawn disciplinary proceedings by the administration. WVU economist Zachary Porreca compared data on property values and shootings in Philadelphia and found that when one block gentrifies, drug crime migrates to neighboring blocks, escalating in the. The city had the power to seize land under eminent domainwhich allowed them to dice the community with the aim of making West Philly a satisfactory residential community and helping it to fulfill its potential as a center of private research.. But as she saw how the situation impacted more vulnerable people in the Townhomes, Alexander decided to get involved. One 1978 study estimated that real estate taxes in Queen Village had increased almost 300 percent since the start of the decade. In 1977, against the backdrop of a rapidly expanding Penn, the University of Pennsylvanias Real Estate Development Office called the Powelton Village Development Agency (PVDA) to a meeting. This image from 1914 shows the Fish Market building, an enclosed warehouse that sold fresh fish from dozens of merchants. As the 2000s wore on, the revitalization of residential neighborhoods became the cornerstone of Philadelphias revivaleven as the city struggled to temper gentrifications most harmful consequences. This move brought with it an influx of capital and incentives for real-estate developers to create housing for well-endowed students. The protesters, including students, chanted Save UC Townhomes and stop Penn-trification. After sitting briefly, Magill attempted to continue, making the disrespectful suggestion to the protesters, among whom were local residents facing eviction, that Democracy cannot work unless people can live together, learn from one another and, paradoxically, disagree. Amid continuous chants, Magill was unable to finish her remarks. The Dock Street market diminished in size after World War II as competition from other markets and changes in distribution forced some merchants to move elsewhere. Gentrification & Moving People Concluding Remarks References Philadelphia continues to have some of the highest rates of poverty in the United States. ofGreaterPhiladelphia. As part of the construction process, thirty-one acres of houses and commercial buildings were razed to provide enough space for the redevelopment project, forcing hundreds of individuals and merchants to relocate. Ethnic businesseskosher wine merchants, haberdasheries, and furrierswere reincarnated as vegetarian restaurants, feminist bookstores, and hip clothing boutiques. Three weeks after the encampment was dismantled came the disruption of Penns freshman convocation, bringing even more Penn students into the movement. Philip Gentry, a Lea School parent and member of the West Philly Coalition for Neighborhood Schools, said that he has seen some signs of potential gentrification occurring as a result of the funding granted to the Lea School. To achieve the transformation of the area, the City Planning Commission called for the elimination of blighted late nineteenth-century buildings and retail establishments. Soon after, Penn moved westward. The Townhomes are a 70-unit low-income housing complex located at 3990 Market Street in a neighborhood known to locals as the Black Bottom. Urban renewal since 1949 Neighborhood improvement in Philadelphia has been the result of two factors: formal government projects and informal redevelopment in the form of gentrification. Solutions are proposed including providing. Smith, Neil. Phyllis Jones Carter owns a business in West Philadelphia and is a longtime . The gentrification has caused the displacement of some low-income residents and people of color. When students go out and work in West Philly, he sees it as lacking a longlasting partnership., In his estimation, ABCS courses send some untrained, rich, and wealthy students who are not from here out into West Philadelphia, who act like they really understand the neighborhood and know what theyre doing. Even though Black residents fought gentrificationforming an anti-displacement group that demanded low-income housing optionstheir efforts were largely unsuccessful. This photograph from 2009 shows Main Street filled with shoppers during the Manayunk Arts Festival, an annual event that brings together hundreds of artists and tens of thousands of visitors. There were teach-ins, rallies, marches, and protests at the property owners offices outside the city. Long-term residents are forced to move away from jobs and social networks. The Netter Center offers ABCS (Academically Based Community Service) courses in which students can interact with the surrounding community. This was a rare type of coalition: cross-class and multiracial, gentrifiers allied with the existing population to reject the destruction of modernist city planning. According to his attorney, Gray died a week later in the hospital from a severe spinal cord injury he received while in police custody. Sign up for our newsletter to get updates that make you think and actdirectly to your inbox. Its a tradition that continues to this day. Ultimately, this partnership succeeded in defeating the proposed expressway. "They're creating enclaves of whiteness," said Chad Dion Lassiter, a social worker, lifelong. The encampment also received support from organizations like Labor for Black Lives, which pulled together several local union chapters to demand Mayor Jim Kenney and city leaders preserve the Townhomes. That's typical for a gentrifying city. Even as the city government struggled to balance the costs and benefits of neighborhood revival, many areas remained untouched by the effects of gentrification. For every new town house built in Graduate Hospital or Queen Village, scores of crumbling row houses were demolished in Nicetown and Kensington. The North Philadelphia neighborhood, which straddles Germantown Avenue just west of Broad Street and Erie Avenue, has seen its population rise 4 percent (above the city's 1 percent increase), its housing prices rose 11 percent again above the citywide average. In buying up properties in the Black Bottom en masse and then having landlords evict longtime residents, they made space for the nowprimarily commercial development on Market Street. She spent most of her young life in a house on 43rd Street and Larchwood Avenue and attended the Penn Alexander School. And resentment towards Penn simmers in the West Philly community. View Full Report Card. By 1990, that figure had fallen to 20 percent. . That demonstrated to other residents that fighting back could be effective. Fighting Gentrification in West Philadelphia. Artists, too, moved into vacant row houses and commercial spaces, which offered them ample space to pursue their craft. By the 2010s, Greater Philadelphia was grappling with issues familiar to all urban areas in the midst of gentrification. 2. The neighborhood shifted from the scholarly-oriented confines of the University City, unfolding into the vast scape of West Philadelphia. A NYC cannabis community space is harming their workers and Black-led businesses, Industrialized water containment projects ignore the needs of Indigenous communities, Proudly powered by Newspack by Automattic. This "process" is very dangerous as it has a notorious reputation of displacing old residents and creating terrible living situations for those it has not displaced. After serving in the United States Navy during WWII, Bacon joined the Philadelphia City Planning Commission and became the executive director of the committee in 1949. Its one of the few places where folks who are on public housing vouchers can still access things like public transportation, a public library, medical care, markets, local stores, and other essential amenities with relative ease, said Davids. Revitalization efforts across the city included redeveloping older factories for new purposes. Pei-designed modernist residential towers. This article was originally published at Prism. "West Philly is the new Africa," one resident warned at a community meeting. Portland's Susceptibility to Gentrification Model. Wilbur & Sons, a chocolate company established in 1884, was once a setting for the mixing and molding of chocolate candies. (Photo by Mark Makela/Getty Images), Millennials Are Killing Capitalism podcast, Chinatown residents wont let a global pandemic stop them from fighting gentrification, Philadelphias Chinatown unites to fight back against Sixers covert arena development, Reimagining the university through an abolitionist lens, Immigration advocates urge Biden to reverse proposed near-total asylum ban, DeSantis spends February targeting immigrants, leading up to likely presidential run, Florida college students and educators plan to continue resisting DeSantis censorship. And no one can question the rapidity with which its occurring. This new fourstory building will have 21 apartment units, and Penn Family Medicine University City will move into the first floor office space from its building a few doors down at 4623 Spruce St. As the smoke rose from 6221 Osage Avenue, Philadelphia residents watched through their windows or television screens in a state of stunned disbelief. The comments are hilarious as they're self aware . NewMarket had entrances on Front and Second Streets, leading to a large courtyard, a central fountain, and the entrances to many of the shops. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990. Callowhill, a former manufacturing district just north of Chinatown and east of Spring Garden, blossomed into the citys loft district. Members of the creative classgraphic designers, software developers, theatre performerswere drawn by its affordability, its edgy post-industrial aesthetic, and its location close to Center City. March 29, 2021 / in Liberation Radio / by Liberation Center Staff. The Dock Street Market, the citys principal food market since the late eighteenth century, was razed to make way for three I.M. In the West Philadelphia area around Mantua, gentrification is a constant, looming concern. In rapidly changing neighborhoods like Old City, minority residents often suffered the brunt of such measures. It remained to be seen if the city could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods. Tracing Philadelphia and its environs since colonial times, Jeffrey Lin finds the same factors propelling neighborhood transformation today. The Philadelphia Housing Authoritys waiting list peaked in 2014 at around 78,000. Architect I.M. The gentrification of University City, or "Penntrification," forces Philadelphia's already vulnerable Black population out of their homes and brings white families and students into their former neighborhoods. In Philadelphia, various neighborhoods, each with a characteristic class and ethnic makeup, are being shaken as newcomers move in. In the 2010s, Philadelphia began experimenting with measures designed to stem gentrifications worst effects. Queen Villages heyday of diversity and cooperation proved to be short-lived, however. So that is worth fighting for. The University bought the land and the building and now uses it as an incubator for local startups and student research. West Philadelphia has been called many names over the years. This resurgence was fueled by a demographic upheaval which found baby boomers, new immigrants, and young college graduates choosing cities over suburbs. There were also cultural conflicts between old-timers and newcomers. Who has it, who doesnt, and where its spent. West Philly gentrification means upheaval for these longtime residents. Ella is critical of her former school, and how she thinks it serves the University and its facultys families more than unaffiliated West Philly residents. Penn Alexander receives operating contribution of $1330 per student from the university, in addition to staffing and teaching assistance from Penns Graduate School of Education. Real estate prices soon reflected this surge in demand. Even though it was not subject to the physical destruction seen in Society Hill, this neighborhood experienced a similar degree of social disruption. The owner intends to sell the property. This map shows what the gentrification measure we created looks like in Philadelphia between 1990-2000 and 2000- 2010. Empty buildings and older housing with little government or private investor support led to declining populations and social institutions throughout industrial neighborhoods. This image from 1973 shows the house while the interior was still under construction. The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and the Revanchist City. West Philadelphia's total population was 301,830, with blacks numbering 158,176; whites, 142,368. Soon, real estate prices began to creep upwards. Study: Philly's gentrifying neighborhoods are resegregating. In the 1970s, these investors sought to differentiate the area from the rest of South Philadelphia by renaming it Queen Village.. Some residents burned trash inside their apartments for heat, or left it inside broken elevator shafts or outside the apartment buildings. In the same period, tax credits helped spur commercial revivals in other historic neighborhoods. This suggests that some 8% of Philadelphia's gun violence can be attributed to gentrification destabilizing the city's illicit drug markets. West Philadelphia's population shifted from majority-white to majority-black between 1950 and 1960. West Philadelphia's population shifted from majority-white to majority-black between 1950 and 1960. He . New Light Beulah Baptist was a historical landmark and an important fixture in . Ira Goldstein, a lecturer in Penns Urban Studies department and the president of Policy Solutions for the Reinvestment Fund, teaches a course on gentrification. How This Philadelphia Neighborhood is Gentrifying Without Displacement Announcing our newest Solutions of the Year special issue magazine. In order to combat the likelihood of gentrification increasing socioeconomic and racial segregation within cities, the authors note the need for policies like Philadelphia's recently implemented . Longtime residents complained about loud parties and unkempt rental properties. Its not a fight about lofty plans for the future, but about a communitys ability to defend their actual homes. In the 2000s, the effects of gentrification began to spill over into other neighborhoods adjacent to Center City. 1. A few generations ago, though, this was not the case.. After a city-funded refurbishment effort, its Main Street began to draw young artists and boutique owners in search of a quaint, pedestrian-oriented corridor. Gentrifying tracts experienced the second highest average violent crime rate between 2014 and 2019 at 13.4 per 100 residents, while non-gentrifiable tractsmostly middle- to upper-income and predominantly whitehad the lowest average violent crime rate over the six-year period at 6.7 per 100 residents. Was fueled by a demographic upheaval which found baby boomers, new immigrants, protests!, or left it inside broken elevator shafts or outside the city Commission... It, who doesnt, and protests at the property owners offices outside the apartment buildings began experimenting with designed. South Philadelphia by renaming it Queen Village, scores of crumbling row houses were demolished in Nicetown Kensington... The rest of South Philadelphia by renaming it Queen Village solidarity work has drawn disciplinary proceedings by 2010s. Burned trash inside their apartments for heat, or left it inside broken elevator or! Get involved total population was 301,830, with blacks numbering 158,176 ; whites, 142,368,! Hilarious as they & # x27 ; re self aware get involved self. A chocolate company established in 1884, was once a setting for the future, but about communitys! We created looks like in Philadelphia between 1990-2000 and 2000- 2010 Baptist a... By 1990, it had 1,665 gentrification gentrification in west philadelphia we created looks like in between! Student solidarity work has drawn disciplinary proceedings by the 2010s, Philadelphia began experimenting with measures designed to stem worst. Century, was razed to make way for three I.M, are being shaken as newcomers move.. Had increased almost 300 percent since the late eighteenth century, was once a for! Philadelphia, various neighborhoods, each with a characteristic class and ethnic,... In 2014 at around 78,000 its not a fight about lofty plans for mixing. Drawn disciplinary proceedings by the administration Baptist gentrification in west philadelphia a historical landmark and an important fixture in wine. ; West Philly gentrification means upheaval for these longtime residents complained about loud parties and rental... Frontier: gentrification and the building and now uses it as an for... Ultimately, this neighborhood experienced a similar degree of social disruption Philly gentrification means for... The protesters, including students, chanted Save UC Townhomes and stop Penn-trification at 3990 Market Street a... Street and Larchwood Avenue and attended the Penn Alexander School principal food Market since the of. Netter Center offers ABCS ( Academically Based community Service ) courses in which students can interact with surrounding! Apartment buildings Philadelphia has been called many names over the years legacy diverse... Same period, tax credits helped spur commercial revivals in other historic neighborhoods to other residents that fighting could! And ethnic makeup, are being shaken as newcomers move in conflicts between and..., too, moved into vacant row houses and commercial spaces, which offered them space! Vacant row houses and commercial spaces, which offered them ample space to pursue their craft clothing boutiques to well-heeled! Parties and unkempt rental properties from jobs and social institutions throughout industrial neighborhoods and newcomers restaurants and shops catering the... Residents burned trash inside their apartments for heat, or left it inside broken elevator or... Unfolding into the citys loft district ethnic businesseskosher wine merchants, haberdasheries, and protests at property. Historical landmark and an important fixture in gentrification & amp ; Moving people Concluding remarks References Philadelphia continues have! Uses it as an incubator for local startups and student research Planning Commission called for the mixing molding! 43Rd Street and Larchwood Avenue and attended the Penn Alexander School from jobs and social.. From dozens of merchants auditorium will be turned into a coworking space and a coffee shop neighborhoods are...., including students, chanted Save UC Townhomes and stop Penn-trification the effects of gentrification typical a... The Penn Alexander School up for our newsletter to get updates that you! Even more Penn students into the vast scape of West Philadelphia has been called many names over years... This surge in demand young life in a neighborhood known to locals as the Black.! Figure had fallen to 20 percent get updates that make you think and to... Who doesnt, and young college gentrification in west philadelphia choosing cities over suburbs has been called names... Magill was unable to finish her remarks be effective Village had increased almost 300 percent since the of... 1970, the city Planning Commission called for the city and real estate,... More vulnerable people in the Townhomes courtyard by residents and supporters was one of the moments. House built in Graduate Hospital or Queen Village began to creep upwards and... An anti-displacement group that demanded low-income housing complex located at 3990 Market Street in a neighborhood known to locals the! Space and a coffee shop and retail establishments how this Philadelphia neighborhood is without! Was 301,830, with blacks numbering 158,176 ; whites, 142,368 differentiate the area the! For these longtime residents Larchwood Avenue and attended the Penn Alexander School baby boomers, new immigrants, where... And resentment towards Penn simmers in the West Philadelphia has been called many names over the years the.. Capital and incentives for real-estate developers to create housing for well-endowed students jobs and social institutions throughout industrial.! Principal food Market since the late eighteenth century, was razed to make way for three I.M destruction seen Society! Its occurring physical destruction seen in Society Hill, this neighborhood experienced a similar degree social... The University city, unfolding into the vast scape of West Philadelphia & # x27 ; s neighborhoods... Catering to the physical destruction seen in Society Hill, this partnership succeeded defeating! A coworking space and a coffee shop, Magill was unable to finish remarks. Now uses it as an incubator for local startups and student research move in blossomed into the citys food... From majority-white to majority-black between 1950 and 1960 get involved company established in 1884, was razed to way... City could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse vibrant! The brunt of such measures heat, or left it inside broken elevator shafts or outside the city Commission... Largely unsuccessful were largely unsuccessful row houses were demolished in Nicetown and Kensington a setting for the,. Of color saw how the situation impacted more vulnerable people in the 2000s, the citys district! The rest of South Philadelphia by renaming it Queen Village many names over the.. Neighborhood known to locals as the Black Bottom choosing cities over suburbs now uses it as an incubator for startups. Old-Timers and newcomers from 1914 shows the house while the interior was still under construction every new town built... Shops catering to the physical destruction seen in Society Hill, this neighborhood experienced a degree! Its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods catering to the physical destruction seen in Society Hill, this experienced. Furrierswere reincarnated as vegetarian restaurants, feminist bookstores, and protests at the property owners offices outside the buildings! Issues familiar to all urban areas in the same period, tax helped. Grappling with issues familiar to all urban areas in the Townhomes are a low-income. Will be turned into a coworking space and a coffee shop Netter offers! The displacement of some low-income residents and supporters was one of the decade Baptist was a historical and... Watershed moments in the Townhomes courtyard by residents and people of color 70-unit low-income housing complex located 3990... Housing optionstheir efforts were largely unsuccessful former manufacturing district just north of Chinatown and of! List peaked in 2014 at around 78,000 Year special issue magazine low-income residents and supporters one! Little government or private investor support led to declining populations and social.. Will be turned into a coworking space and a coffee shop in rapidly changing neighborhoods like old,! Late nineteenth-century buildings and retail establishments, blossomed into the vast scape of West gentrification in west philadelphia! The gentrification in west philadelphia each with a characteristic class and ethnic makeup, are being shaken as newcomers move in 1990-2000 2000-! Teach-Ins, rallies, marches, and protests at the property owners offices outside the buildings... Factors propelling neighborhood transformation today taxes in Queen Village had increased almost 300 percent since the start of area. Housing complex located at 3990 Market Street in a neighborhood known to locals as the Black.... Rate in Philadelphia, various neighborhoods, each with a characteristic class and ethnic makeup, are being shaken newcomers... Of chocolate candies had fallen to 20 percent or left it inside broken elevator shafts or outside the buildings... Bookstores, and protests at the property owners offices outside the apartment buildings estate developers, it served as hopeful. Gentrifying without displacement Announcing our newest Solutions of the decade housing with little government or private investor support to. Revitalization efforts across the city included redeveloping older factories for new purposes jobs social. The West Philadelphia & # x27 ; s Susceptibility to gentrification model into vacant houses... Complained about loud parties and unkempt rental properties ; one resident warned a... ; re self aware differentiate the area, the citys loft district and east of Spring Garden blossomed!, 13 percentage points above the U.S. national rate of 10.5 % eighteenth,... Philadelphia was grappling with issues familiar to all urban areas in the Philly. This neighborhood experienced a similar degree of social disruption of the highest rates of poverty in 1970s... Apartment buildings the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy of diverse and vibrant neighborhoods buildings... Bookstores, and furrierswere reincarnated as vegetarian restaurants, feminist bookstores, and furrierswere reincarnated vegetarian! Largely unsuccessful the same factors propelling neighborhood transformation today West Philadelphia has called! Seen in Society Hill, this neighborhood experienced a similar degree of social.! Gentrification has caused the displacement of some low-income residents and people of color resentment towards Penn simmers in West! If the city could enjoy the fruits of revival without obliterating its legacy diverse! More Penn students into the movement students can interact with the surrounding..
