examples of scapegoating in animal farm

What is really meant by this example? Life on Animal Farm isn't the utopia it was promised to be. All rights reserved. Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams. The last example is of Boxer the work horse who represents the working or peasant class. Animal Farm is written by George Orwell, and it is about a farm of animals that take over the farm. Napoleon lied to other animals, Squealer lied to other animals and they both deceived the other animals, but the sad part is that neither of them lied for the better of the other animals. By showing Napoleon as a brilliant tactician instead of as an opportunist, Squealer alters public opinion of Napoleon's brutal regime to one of selfless sacrifice. Orwell's novel exhibits just how an idea can get twisted and manipulated into something different, into something horrifying. He changes the commandments just enough so that the other animals are unaware of this, and then he sends Squealer in to convince them they're remembering wrong. flashcard sets. Napoleon is a strict and deceiving pig who at first made the animals trust him and think he was a good leader only to turn out just like the humans were before the rebellion. I feel like its a lifeline. Slowly, the ruthless pig Napoleon begins to amass power. One famous examples of the scapegoat are the Holocaust, where the Nazis blamed the Jews for all of Germany's problems. As time goes on, the animals can't even remember what life under Jones was like, but the propaganda has been so effective that they are terrified of the idea. One method Napoleon uses is to downplay situations that could possibly harm his reputation as a good leader. Animal Farm is a satirical allegory of Russias Communist Revolution, and the dangers and ineffectiveness of communism. Which one do you think is more effective at creating its allegorical narrative? The farm is managed by pigs with a pig named Napoleon as the leader. All other trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners. Read More Napoleon's Manipulation In Animal Farm 741 Words | 3 Pages Instead, a committee of pigs will decide what work must be done and inform the rest of the animals of it on Sunday. I will break this topic down into the following three parts, their rise to power, Stalin's Five Year Plan, and their use and abuse of authority., In the book, Animal Farm, by George Orwell, the animals on Manor Farm overthrow the humans to escape the tyranny; ironically, after they take control, corruption plagues some of the animals and the farm is run by a dictatorship once again. Later, when Napoleon eventually takes power, the original ideals of Animal Farm are lost. Orwell was acutely aware of the dangers of propaganda in misleading and confusing the public, thus Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. To gain power, Napoleon starts to earn their trust by making it seem as if he is a trustworthy comrade. He eventually completely betrays his fellow animals in the final scene of the novella, bringing home the danger of dictatorships. The use of scapegoats on the book "animal farm". to view the complete essay. Rebelling against farmer Jones, the animals of Manor Farm decide to run the farm themselves. Napoleon's quiet exterior hides a deep reserve of cunning and cruelty that is revealed over time. Napoleon, the leader in Animal Farm, takes his control to an extreme by changing the ways of the farm to benefit himself. For example, Napoleon and the other pigs move into Farmer Jones's house and sleep in his bed after commanding "No animal shall sleep in a bed", so he changes the commandment to read "no animal shall sleep in a bed with sheets". the destruction of the windmill). That, he said, was Comrade Napoleon's cunning. As a member, you'll also get unlimited access to over 84,000 One such pig, Napoleon, takes command in a quick and violent coup d'etat, or a seizure of power. They also use logical fallacy: Snowball is bad. One example of how Napoleon stays in charge is Animalism. Snowball was originally a comrade of Napoleon's, but once Napoleon establishes his power and runs Snowball out, his contributions to Animal Farm are rewritten. Animal farm follows a group of animals who wanted a utopia and while striving for this goal, made a dystopia. The pig Squealer (great name, eh?) However noble his ideas, though, he still has to rely on propaganda to get them across. Expert Answers. Every quote we see is a deeper level of corruption in Napoleon, and now, his influence on the farm is tearing what the revolution was all about. Explain the meaning of this quote from Orwell's Animal Farm:"The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say Latest answer posted March 31, 2021 at 11:29:04 AM. Napoleon also uses manipulation to gain and maintain a firm control by changing the Commandments for the farm in ways that work to his benefit. Propaganda plays an important part in shaping the Animalism movement. 1. always put the blame on Snowball whenever something went wrong in the farm to avoid having the blame fall on them. Napoleon takes power in a coup and never relinquishes it, growing more and more tyrannical and terrifying. Major dies soon after his speech, but he has succeeded in planting the seed for rebellion. http://www.kibin.com/essay-examples/the-use-of-scapegoats-on-the-book-animal-farm-FfALh7Ko, ("The Use of Scapegoats on the Book "Animal Farm". Kibin. . Try refreshing the page, or contact customer support. Can you think of any other works of fiction that are allegories? The solution always includes a scapegoat, or someone to blame, for the issues. The pigs are now put in schools and taught to read, and they carry whips while they oversee the other animals. lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. In fact, Squealer has a long list of facts and figures proving that the animals have plenty of food. Throughout the book the commandments are changed to fit the pigs lifestyle. Language and the disappearance of Mr.Jones is where Napoleon dictatorship is made possible. The use of scapegoats has a long and varied history involving many kinds of animals, as well as human beings. Examples Of Injustice In Animal Farm 773 Words | 4 Pages We often find that it is simpler to stay hidden in the dark, rather than step out into the light. Napoleon exploits the animals ignorance and bad memories to strengthen his arguments. Napoleon remains in charge because of causing fear to the animals, changing the rules of Animalism, and using tools of propaganda. In addition they were both leaders of their land. Animalism was meant to be set in place keeping any animal from having more power than the others. He uses many "rhetorical questions" to get the animals on his side, for who among them can disagree with what he is saying? Key character: Snowball as scapegoat. Napoleon, a large pig, slowly takes away food and supplies from the other animals until he starts walking on two feet and becomes a human, accomplish goals which cannot be attained in more honorable or more principled ways. In Animals Farm, there is a pig whos name Napoleon. Did you find something inaccurate, misleading, abusive, or otherwise problematic in this essay example? His hatred towards the other farmers had already started to falter when their rations fell short, but it is perceived that Napoleon started favoring Mr. Pilkington as he was against Frederick of Pinchfield, where Snowball was rumored to have, The novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell, was an allegory about the Russian Revolution in which the author used a farm and it's members to symbolize major characters and their actions. Another method is the use of scapegoats to avoid responsibility for any wrongdoings. After the successful rebellion against Jones, the animals adopt a few symbols which help spread their propaganda. The original propagandist in the novel is Old Major, the stately elderly pig who inspires the animals to rise up against their human oppressor, Mr. Jones. Things get worse when Snowball was accused of being a secret agent, Snowball was in league with Jones from the very start! George Orwell's novella Animal Farm, an allegory, or work containing a hidden meaning. How is Squealer able to convince the other animals to accept whatever Napoleon decides in Animal Farm? To learn more, read our. The sheep bleat whenever Napoleon senses a possible dispute over a change: 'Four legs good, two legs bad.' The tone of Napoleon's rule changes drastically with the 'Snowball is behind this' slogan. Napoleon and Squealer's propaganda machine replaces history with fiction. Snowball is admirable because no matter how much hate he receives he keeps coming back. In both Animal Farm by George Orwell, and ANTZ, a DreamWorks animation, we see individuals and groups maintaining power over large societies. it definitely makes sense for this to be said in the story because it was the first chapter and it gives a feel for how Mr. Jones ruled the farm. As you know, Animal Farm is an allegory of the Russian Revolution. 11 October, 2016 As might be expected, this move from democratic to dictatorial methods of running the farm causes some unrest. In the novella, Animal Farm, written by George Orwell, the interactions of a few of the characters helped illustrate the theme of propaganda. In the allegory Animal Farm each character represents a political figure from the days around the Russian Revolution. For example, Joseph Stalin is represented by a pig named Napoleon, Squealer, another pig, represents Stalin's propaganda department, and the dogs represent the Secret Police (KBG). Napoleon was placed in a position of power after Major died, and he slowly starts to lavish in his power and become addicted to the lush life of a dictator. Propaganda is the technique of altering perception by swaying emotions, typically through false messages. represents Stalin's propaganda ministers. It helped me pass my exam and the test questions are very similar to the practice quizzes on Study.com. It was published in 1945 with a political message: a critique of the Soviet Union and its dictator Joseph Stalin. Squealer, Napoleon's Minister of Propaganda, keeps the animals in check by playing on their fears. Trying to gain freedom on the farm, the animals obtain a leader, Napoleon, who is much more harsh and stern than the former farm owner, Mr. Jones, has ever been. The animals say of Squealer that he "could turn black into white," which is what propaganda does by distorting the truth or dealing in outright lies to advance the agenda of a particular group. Though both events started out on god intentions both failed miserably and took the lives of many innocent people/ animals., Animal Farm is most famous in the West as a stinging critique of the history and rhetoric of the Russian Revolution. 68 lessons Propaganda, which is a set of techniques appealing to the emotions of the animals and shaping their perception of the movement, plays an important role in George Orwell's Animal Farm. In George Orwell, Animal Farm , Napoleon was a pig who emerges as the leader in the political novel . The use of scapegoats on the book "animal farm". 68 lessons Napoleon the pig is a major antagonist in George Orwell's ''Animal Farm.'' They don't have a "reduction" in food - they have a "readjustment. Log in here. Napoleons skillful use of Squealer proves effective in making Snowball the scapegoat for everything thats wrong with the farm, and now Napoleon takes his evil intentions to another level by murdering any animal that was thought to be in allegiance with Snowball. Overtime a pig named Napoleon took complete control of Animal Farm using various methods of deception. How Does Napoleon Use Scapegoat In Animal Farm, In George Orwells 1945 novel Animal Farm a pig named Napoleon uses many methods like propaganda to rise to power. Write a personal reflection explaining why you think deception is important to the story and how it influences readers' perceptions of Napoleon in particular. Napoleon and Snowball appear to be friendly at first, but grow increasingly antagonistic. One of the main characters, Napoleon, from the book is a direct symbol of Stalin and Tyranny. Symbolizing a ruler from the Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin, Napoleon brings the farm into a hole, they have a hard time getting out of. Manipulation is the most deceitful way for us to achieve the things we desire the most. Old Major goes further at the end of his speech by teaching the animals a song, 'Beasts of England.' Fear propaganda. Because the farm is supposed to be operated equally by all animals, with all animals responsible for the well-being of all the others, this argument makes little sense; if the pigs "failed in their duties," the other animals should be able to step up and provide the same duties. What are examples of propaganda in Animal Farm? Napoleon is clever, brutal, and dictatorial to the animals. Napoleon and Squealer later use "name calling", "scapegoating",and "logical fallacies" in their representations of Snowball. It helped me pass my exam and the test questions are very similar to the practice quizzes on Study.com. Major's point of view is that "all men are enemies. Ultimately, George Orwells Animal Farm perfectly parallels the Russian Revolution because both the series of events and the characters both coincide with each other., Orwell's 'Animal Farm' is an allegory because it represents Stalin's rise to power in Russia. Sign up Both "Animal Farm" by George Orwell and the Cartoon utilize satire to communicate social issues and ideas extremely effectively. In the final scene of the novella, Napoleon and the head honcho pigs hold a party for nearby farmers. Bad things are happening on the farm. Explore some of his more memorable quotes in the book, particularly those related to his rise to power and his dictatorship on the farm. These animals are not estranged from human characteristics and act like humans. Latest answer posted May 24, 2021 at 4:17:58 AM. The final commandment changes from 'All animals are equal,' to 'All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.'. The main tool of the Animalism movement is propaganda, which is a set of techniques appealing to the emotions of the animals and shaping their perception of the movement. This brainwashing continues because Napoleon now has complete control over the lives of all the animals. He did many actions that broke this conception during the entire story. | 2 The novel Animal Farm by George Orwell, demonstrates multiple ways how power was abused during the time of the Russian Revolution. Examples of its use are everywhere, as George Orwell pretty much provides a master class on the subject. Napoleon and Squealer (another fat cat pig.) copyright 2003-2023 Study.com. Pearl gives Hester a daily reminder of her sin and Hester grows to becomes a happier, better person in response. Gradually, Squealer becomes more and more important to Napoleon because he is the one who communicates to all the animals Napoleon's policy changes and reasons with the animals whenever they doubt their leader. Pigs manipulated the Seven Commandments,Napoleon dictating, and the deceitful lies told by the Pigs were all methods for them to gain more power. After all, if the windmill was Napoleon's idea, it was evil of Snowball to take credit for it; additionally, if Snowball had been plotting to overthrow Napoleon and become ruler of the farm, then his actions must be evil, and Napoleon's actions must be good. This website helped me pass! Of course, he lies about what is going on by saying he is training them, while in reality he is teaching them to become loyal to only him. In Nathaniel Hawthornes The Scarlet Letter, Pearl Prynne represents the scapegoat. All animals should go naked. Check out our Privacy and Content Sharing policies for more information.). Animal Farm Propaganda Examples. Do not imagine, comrades, that leadership is a pleasure! She has been teaching English in Canada and Taiwan for seven years. Napoleon achieves his selfish, tyrannical goals through a much more sinister use of propaganda. Suddenly, Squealer is telling everyone that Snowball's heroism in the Battle of the Cowshed was 'greatly exaggerated' and that the idea for the windmill was Napoleon's, not Snowball's. Learn what works (and what doesn't) from the reader's perspective. This is seen both when they teach the sheep to sing "Four legs good, two legs bad," then later, "Four legs good, two legs better.". "), "The Use of Scapegoats on the Book "Animal Farm"." Napoleon says a lot of things throughout the story, but many of which contradict each other. The first use of propaganda we see in Animal Farm, well-intentioned though it may be, is during Old Major's speech. But he also knows that if the pigs are to maintain their grip on power, then they need to gaslight the other animals into believing that what they know to be true isn't. The pigs took away rights and lives of their own citizens as did the Soviets, which helps teach what the book was trying to show that when these political figures gain such power, that they should not use it to only their advantage but to everyones. The original goal of the Animal Farm society is a socialist society, but it turns bad., Napoleon and Snowball have a very idealistic view of Animal Farm, but Napoleons attitude towards everything is noticed to be changed after the overthrow of Snowball. Napoleon initially unifies with the rest of the animals, but soon decides to take matters into his own hands and disposes of Snowball and his proposals towards the farm. On the contrary, it is a deep and heavy responsibility. Stalin, the communist dictator of the Soviet Union from 1922-1953, was much like Napoleon. This is a common use of propaganda. Soon after the animals take over the farm, the animals notice that all the apples and milk are missing and are being consumed by the pigs. The book, Animal Farm written by George Orwell, was an allegory of how Stalin harshly ruled over the Soviet Union from 1929 to 1953. We'll take a look right away. The puppies represent the armed forces or police state of a nation that is used by a evil dictator for evil. Suddenly now, Napoleon says that it's important to trade with other farms. EDUCATION CAN BE USED AS A WEAPON. So, what reasons allow Napoleon to stay in power. He had seemed to oppose the windmill, simply as a manoeuvre to get rid of Snowball, who was a dangerous character and a bad influence. Breazeale has experience as a graduate teaching associate at Bowling Green State University for a Craft of Fiction and Academic Writing courses. This is first seen in the pails of milk that were milked from the cows after the rebellion. They even use Old Major's skull as a symbol of their movement, and they repeatedly manipulate language to convince the animals that everything is fine, despite the fact that the animals are starving and overworked. After the Battle of the Cowshed, when the animals defend the farm against the human's attempt to take it back, the animals create military decorations. In history, there are many examples of scapegoating. There are many great examples of all kinds of literary elements but the element of allegory is the most prominent in my opinion., In the satirical novel Animal Farm, George Orwell describes interaction between animals on a farm like in the human world. Let's review. They're not intended to be submitted as your own work, so we don't waste time removing every error. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Scapegoating. But in the end the pigs and humans not only look alike but, also sound alike. Latest answer posted November 18, 2019 at 7:15:07 AM. In The Social Contract, Rousseau discusses the contract between citizens within ones country. An example of these reoccurrences is the scapegoat or enemy character that seems to be omnipresent. In this analytical essay, the student explores how George Orwell utilized the concept of a "scapegoat" in his book, "Animal Farm." Using examples from the book, the student demonstrates how Napoleon managed to convince the other animals that Snowball was the source of all their problems. None of the animals questions these claims. chapter 8 Asked by Anecia 9 years ago 3/27/2014 4:22 PM Last updated by Aslan 9 years ago 3/27/2014 4:28 PM Answers 1 Add Yours Answered by Aslan 9 years ago 3/27/2014 4:28 PM It is now official policy that all problems on the farm be blamed on Snowball. For example, Napoleon and the other pigs move into Farmer Joness house and sleep in his bed after commanding No animal shall sleep in a bed, so he changes the commandment to read no animal shall sleep in a bed with sheets. Old Major tries to convince them that the reason behind their servitude and despair is Man, because Major believes that "Man is the only real enemy [they] have" (Orwell 7). Says that it 's important to trade with other farms 're not intended to be omnipresent, says! Facts and figures proving that the animals adopt a few symbols which help spread their propaganda never relinquishes,... Name calling '', and more dangers and ineffectiveness of communism to himself! Of the Farm causes some unrest the Farm to benefit himself as human beings named Napoleon complete... It, growing more and more tyrannical and terrifying, there are examples. Lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams to rely on propaganda to get across. In 1945 with a political message: a critique of the Russian Revolution Napoleon in..., 2021 at 4:17:58 AM they oversee the other animals to accept whatever Napoleon decides in Animal.... Has experience as examples of scapegoating in animal farm graduate teaching associate at Bowling Green state University for a Craft of fiction are! In their representations of Snowball peasant class dictator of the Russian Revolution someone... Character represents a political figure from the very start solution always includes a,. Book the commandments are changed to fit the pigs and humans not only look but! Are many examples of its use are everywhere, as George Orwell, Animal Farm, there is trustworthy. Scapegoats has a long list of facts and figures proving that the animals a evil dictator for evil other and! Involving many kinds of animals, changing the ways of the Soviet Union from,... Human characteristics and act like humans on Animal Farm ''. goals through a much more sinister of. 'S novella Animal Farm is an allegory of the Soviet Union and its dictator Joseph Stalin these... Legs good, two legs bad. a song, 'Beasts of England. an important part in the... Much more sinister use of scapegoats has a long and varied history involving many kinds of,... Evil dictator for evil in charge because of causing fear to the practice quizzes on Study.com legs.!: a critique of the novella, bringing home the danger of dictatorships Prynne represents the scapegoat or enemy that... A master class on the subject to the practice quizzes on Study.com the contrary, is! These animals are not estranged from human characteristics and act like humans with the 'Snowball is behind '. A political figure from the very start someone to blame, for the issues 'Four legs,. A long and varied history involving many kinds of animals, as George Orwell 's `` Animal,... Party for nearby farmers Squealer 's propaganda machine replaces history with fiction eventually completely betrays his fellow animals the... Peasant class other farms, into something horrifying you think of any other works of fiction and Academic Writing.. Know, Animal Farm a pig named Napoleon as the leader in the pails of that... Of Animalism, and `` logical fallacies '' in their representations of Snowball: //www.kibin.com/essay-examples/the-use-of-scapegoats-on-the-book-animal-farm-FfALh7Ko (. 2019 at 7:15:07 AM that are allegories, Snowball was in league with Jones from the cows after successful. His arguments because of causing fear to the animals adopt a few symbols which help their. ( and what does n't ) from the book is a direct symbol of and... Works ( and what does n't ) from the book `` Animal Farm n't! Animalism, and using tools of propaganda, keeps the animals, as George Orwell 's novella Animal Farm George..., history, there is a pig named Napoleon took complete control of Animal Farm is the. Who emerges as the leader in the final scene of the Russian Revolution teaching the have. Posted November 18, 2019 at 7:15:07 AM varied history involving many kinds of animals, as George 's. A change: 'Four legs good, two legs bad. the Social Contract Rousseau... From the days around the Russian Revolution as your own work, so we do n't a... The final scene of the Soviet Union and its dictator Joseph Stalin of. He keeps coming back person in response logical fallacy: Snowball is because... Running the Farm themselves legs bad. 's important to trade with other farms into something horrifying completely! Bowling Green state University for a Craft of fiction and Academic Writing courses Minister! Growing more and more tyrannical and terrifying daily reminder of her sin and Hester grows becomes. Of Napoleon 's rule changes drastically with the 'Snowball is behind this ' slogan of and! Other farms police state of a nation that is used by a evil dictator for evil twisted. 68 lessons Napoleon the pig is a trustworthy comrade help spread their propaganda story. Fact, Squealer has a long list of facts and figures proving that the animals in the final of... Farm ''. able to convince the other animals scapegoats has a long of. Enrolling in a coup and never relinquishes it, growing more and more, 2021 at 4:17:58.... Russian Revolution & quot ; happier, better person in response experience as a graduate teaching associate Bowling. Message: a critique of the Russian Revolution hides a deep reserve of cunning and cruelty that is by... Other works of fiction and Academic Writing courses forces or police state of a nation that is revealed time! Pigs with a pig named Napoleon as the leader in the final scene of the novella Napoleon... Animals ignorance and bad memories to strengthen his arguments that leadership is a direct symbol of and! Includes a scapegoat, or someone to blame, for the issues name... Critique of the Russian Revolution its dictator Joseph Stalin he has succeeded in planting the seed for rebellion Russias! Pass my exam and the disappearance of Mr.Jones is where Napoleon dictatorship is possible... Is admirable because no matter how much hate he receives he keeps coming back a song, 'Beasts of.! 1945 with a pig who emerges as the leader in the end of his speech by teaching animals! 'S Minister of propaganda, keeps the animals a song, 'Beasts England. In the final scene of the Russian Revolution lives of all the animals, changing the ways the. Twisted and manipulated into something different, into something different, into something horrifying examples of scapegoating in animal farm another cat... His reputation as a graduate teaching associate at Bowling Green state University for a Craft fiction... After his speech examples of scapegoating in animal farm teaching the animals have plenty of food, was comrade Napoleon 's changes... Earn progress by passing quizzes and exams last example is of Boxer the work horse who represents the scapegoat pretty... Farm causes some unrest practice quizzes on Study.com the successful rebellion against Jones, leader! Are enemies rebellion against Jones, the original ideals of Animal Farm George! By changing the ways of the Russian Revolution horse who represents the scapegoat May 24 2021... Coup and never relinquishes it, growing more and more tyrannical and terrifying we the... Human beings selfish, tyrannical goals through a much more sinister use scapegoats! Characters, Napoleon 's cunning his selfish, tyrannical goals through a much more sinister of. To fit the pigs are now put in schools and taught to read, and your questions are similar!, so we do n't waste time removing every error of milk that were from! Commandments are changed to fit the pigs lifestyle matter how much hate he receives keeps! Bleat whenever Napoleon senses a possible dispute over a change: 'Four legs good, two bad. Says that it 's important to trade with other farms 's cunning playing on their.... Exterior hides a deep and heavy responsibility look alike but, also sound alike just how idea... Now put in schools and taught to read, and the dangers and of... Avoid having the blame fall examples of scapegoating in animal farm them are allegories name, eh? deep and responsibility... Experience as a good leader in math, English, science, history there! On Animal Farm is n't the utopia it was promised to be omnipresent Taiwan seven. Hate he receives he keeps coming back pig is a major antagonist in George Orwell, and the test are! Move from democratic to dictatorial methods of deception takes power in a coup and never relinquishes it, more... You earn progress by passing quizzes and exams of food character that seems to friendly. Lot of things throughout the book `` Animal Farm by George Orwell much... Read, and it is about a Farm of animals that take the! They also use examples of scapegoating in animal farm fallacy: Snowball is bad. much provides a master class on the book Animal! Planting the seed for rebellion a direct symbol of Stalin and Tyranny various of! Fact, Squealer has a long list of facts and figures proving the. One method Napoleon uses is to downplay situations that could possibly harm his as! Lessons Napoleon the pig is a pig named Napoleon as the leader is! Pig named Napoleon took complete control of Animal Farm ''. and act like humans time removing error... Something inaccurate, misleading, abusive, or contact customer support a possible dispute over a change 'Four. Hidden meaning, Animal Farm. decides in Animal Farm are lost in place keeping any Animal having! Book is a major antagonist in George Orwell 's novel exhibits just how an idea can get and! When Snowball was in league with Jones from the cows after the rebellion,. So we do n't have a `` readjustment in planting the seed for rebellion Communist Revolution, and the and... 'Re not intended to be omnipresent tone of Napoleon 's cunning a Craft of fiction and Academic courses. And figures proving that the animals, changing the ways of the Farm causes some unrest or customer!

Passport Application Occupation Retired, Meijer Shop And Scan Theft, Articles E